Review: Elsinore

“Hamlet just walked off the stage,” the actors whisper from backstage, in a panic. It’s early in a 1989 performance of Shakespeare’s classic at the National Theater in London, and for reasons no one can quite explain, the actor playing the melancholy Dane has left the stage, stormed to his dressing room, and slammed the door. It’s only then that we see the name of the actor occupying the dressing room (and the role): Daniel Day-Lewis.

I’d heard this story before, and you might have too. What I didn’t know was the story of the actor who replaced him: Ian Charleson, a Welsh actor best known for co-starring in Chariots of Fire, who took on the role — generally agreed to be one of, if not the most, challenging roles in all of the theater — while ill with AIDS. His story is told in Elsinore, a powerful new drama from director Simon Stone, with Andrew Scott as Charleson. They’re attempting a number of things at once: a backstage drama, an AIDS story, a character study. They do them all splendidly.

Stephen Beresford’s screenplay is casual but informative in its handling of the tricky specifics; we get a clear understanding of the stages of sickness, and the options available for treatment at that point in the crisis. They’re laid out clearly by Ian’s doctor, Margaret Johnson (Olivia Colman, stern but wry), who is not at all on board with the part where Ian will exhaust himself by learning and rehearsing a four-hour tragedy “about being alive, and becoming dead,” according to the play’s director Richard Eyre (Johnny Flynn). He’s unaware of Ian’s diagnosis when he offers him the role, but Ian is insistent: “I want to do it. I choose to do it. I can do it.”

One of the loveliest qualities here is the manner in which the camaraderie of the acting company and the rehearsal process mirrors the queer community and the various kinds of support he finds; these are both refuges of people who often have to make their own families, and surround themselves with the necessary emotional guardrails. Beresford’s script also gets considerable mileage out of Ian’s strained relationship with the out queer filmmaker Derek Jarman (David Dawson), and their scenes – which could have been very “what do you think, George Harrison of the Beatles” – are pointed and riveting, deftly using Jarman as a stand-in for the kind of life and career Ian turned away from.

Scott, who has rapidly ascended to one of the most reliable screen actors we’ve got, is among the credited producers, and it’s not hard to see why. At its base, this is a dream role for an actor: he gets to play a) a real person, b) a dying person, and c) Hamlet. And he is, unsurprisingly, a great Hamlet (so much so that now I want to just see him in the play), delivering Shakespeare’s sharp dialogue and introspective speeches with vigor and intensity. But then there’s another level at work with the external circumstances at play, so these familiar speeches take on extra poignancy when shined through that specific prism. The “alas, poor Yorick” speech is even more contemplative and ruminating, for example, when delivered by an actor who knows he’ll be joining Yorick soon. 

But Scott is just as striking, so real and so present, when playing Ian himself. I can’t shake the power of a lingering close-up as he waits for his parents to come into his hospital room, unaware that he is even gay, much less that he’s dying — it’s a jaw-dropping moment, intensely dramatizing a private moment with unguarded intimacy. (The great Peter Mullin plays his father, and the pulverizing poignancy of his brief role shows exactly why you get Peter Mullin to come into your movie for five minutes.)

This all sounds crushingly depressing, but rest assured, Elsinore is about as funny and affirming as a film about an actor playing Hamlet while dying of AIDS could possibly be. And there’s real suspense as well; when it’s time for Ian to finally take the stage, we’re genuinely nervous, with him and for him. Can he pull this off? Well, the show must go on, as they say.  What a story. What a performance. What a film. 

“Elisnore” is out Friday in select theaters Friday, with expansions to follow on November 25 and December 4.

Jason Bailey is a film critic and historian, and the author of five books. His work has appeared in The New York Times, The Playlist, Vanity Fair, Vulture, Rolling Stone, Slate, and more. He is the co-host of the podcast "A Very Good Year."

Back to top